In Hive or Castle, Duty
Without Power
The New York Times
Wednesday, May 16, 2007
By NATALIE ANGIER
Published: May 15, 2007
I never much cared for royalty, although I admit
that, for reasons my family and I are still struggling to understand,
I named my first cat “Princess Bubbles.”
Nevertheless, as I watched Queen Elizabeth II
float serenely last week through her swooning colonial multitudes,
here chatting with Goddard engineers on the wonders of the space
age, there catching the president on blunders about the queen’s
age, I couldn’t help but doff a small mental tiara to the
great lady.
Such sober poise and unpompous stances! She’s
majestic, all right, her regalness clearly born, made and thrust
upon her every day of her life. In so many ways, Elizabeth reminded
me of another monarch I admire: the honeybee queen, that stoical,
beloved mother to the worker masses in a beehive. Sure, Her Highness
may go in for pastel solids and Her Hymenoptera for fuzzy stripes,
but both are tiny, attractive celebrities prone to being swarmed.
Both are kept meticulously well-groomed by a retinue of handlers
and are fed high-quality foods generally unavailable to the proletariat.
Both are, yes, long-lived. And both share the dubious honor of
having enormous social responsibility but very little power.
“The queen bee, like the queen of England,
is not the ruler, and she doesn’t tell anybody what to do,”
said Gene E. Robinson, a professor of integrative biology at the
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. “But she makes
things work, and she makes everything better by being around.”
Dr. Robinson and other researchers are trying
to understand the deep nature of the honeybee: why it behaves
as it does, how a young bee knows it’s time to grow up and
get out of the house, how an older bee finds its way back to the
house after a hard day’s work, and what distinguishes a
queen bee from the tens of thousands of worker bees that surround
her.
The researchers are driven by more than a perfectly
understandable besottedness with bees. They see bees, with their
comma-sized brains, compact genomes and circumscribed set of stereotyped
behaviors, as offering a relatively simple and politically unobjectionable
system for deciphering the biology of behavior. To that end, they
are mapping out the chemical sequence of honeybee DNA and recently
published a rough draft of the bee’s 11,000 or so genes.
Researchers are also scrambling for clues, any clues, into the
recent, baffling disappearance of honeybees across the United
States, a potentially catastrophic trend that threatens the hundred
or more food crops dependent on bees for pollination.
Unlike the great bee die-offs of the past, when
mites or other deadly pathogens left mounds of bee corpses lying
by the hives, in the newest crisis there are as yet no bee bodies
to forensically explore. The bees are simply flying off by the
billions as though into the void. When beekeepers check affected
nests, the combs are filled with pollen and honey, but there is
almost nobody home: the workers have largely vanished, leaving
the queen in an unnatural state of quiet near-solitude, helpless
on her own.
That a queen cannot survive without her court
is a testament to the incomparable interdependence of social insect
society, the pulsing, groupthinking superorganism that is the
honeybee hive. Honeybees in a colony are as close-knit as cashmere,
sharing up to three-quarters of their genes, compared with the
50 percent link between human siblings, and that strong kinship
helps explain their highly cooperative style. They are also nearly
all female. Less than 1 percent of the hive dwellers are drones,
short-lived, bug-eyed males built to mate once with a queen before
dropping dead to the ground with an audible pop.
There is no top-down structure to honeybee society,
no central command post or leaders with whips. Power is disseminated
through the hive, and daily decisions about, say, whose turn it
is to feed the larvae, take out the trash or fan the nectar into
honey are made consensually and regionally, through a constant
exchange of chemical, tactile and visual cues. “It’s
a lot of local responses to local stimuli,” Dr. Robinson
said. “Little things collectively give rise to decisions.”
As for the queen, she is so far from being a
decisive potentate that she can seem goofily out of the loop.
When a colony is ready to move to a new hive, for example, about
three dozen scout bees appraise the local real estate, consult
with one another and with other workers and finally, communally,
settle on the best new spot. Come moving day, the queen has no
idea where to go and must be shown the way.
The queen hasn’t time for gossip or bee-blogging. She is
too busy laying eggs. That is her sole job, and one that she alone
can do, for the other females in the hive lack working reproductive
parts.
Day in, day out, the queen remains in her climate-controlled
chamber laying eggs, one or two per minute, maybe 2,500 a day.
All the while she is pushed, provisioned and plucked by her retinue
of nurses, her bristles kept spotless, her mandibles kept stuffed
with the nutritious, high-calorie, egg-enabling delicacy called
royal jelly. “I’d say that being queen is the absolute
worst job in the hive,” said May R. Berenbaum, a professor
of entomology at the University of Illinois. “At least the
foragers get out for fresh air and some scenery.”
What the queen lacks in liberty, though, she
makes up for in longevity. Whereas worker bees live only two or
three months, a queen lives two or three years, and some have
been known to survive to age 8.
Scientists are just beginning to understand how
the queen so dramatically outlives her workers, when she and they
arise from the same genetic roots. Dr. Robinson and his colleagues
reported last month that a queen’s early exposure to royal
jelly, which allowed her to mature into a queen rather than a
worker, may offer her a lifetime of antioxidant protection against
cellular decay.
However she manages, the queen bee defies the
normal rule in biology that organisms must choose between a long
life and high fecundity. Her loyal subjects need her, and so she
doughtily broods on. Now will they please return the favor and
come back home?